
And I don’t just mean on the blogs.
Rants like this one are popping up all over the internet these days, and they’re convincing a lot of people to take action. But one of the central tenets of the argument continues to bother me.
It’s spelled out best by Amy Webb for Slate, who shares the story of “Kate”…
With every status update, YouTube video, and birthday blog post, Kate’s parents are preventing her from any hope of future anonymity.
That poses some obvious challenges for Kate’s future self. It’s hard enough to get through puberty. Why make hundreds of embarrassing, searchable photos freely available to her prospective homecoming dates? If Kate’s mother writes about a negative parenting experience, could that affect her ability to get into a good college? We know that admissions counselors review Facebook profiles and a host of other websites and networks in order to make their decisions.
Now let me just make sure I have this straight. Are we worried that a baby picture or a story about little Kate’s growing pains might someday prevent her from getting into the college of her dreams? Or are we under the impression that we might somehow be able to keep Kate”off the grid” until she’s old enough to join Facebook and ruin her online identity for herself?
Of course we have to set limits on our sharing (or oversharing), but really, that’s a separate issue. This more specific concern, that we might somehow ruin our kids’ lives by sharing their baby pictures with our friends and family on Facebook, feels like it’s going a bit too far.
Then again, I have to admit I’m a little hesitant to post shots of Austin here, and I frequently debate how much I might share when Mark and I decide to have a child of our own. There’s a discomfort with the internet (that flows naturally from its youth) that rightly makes us take a second look. The world is changing, privacy is changing, and our circles are expanding… so how do we make sense of it all?
What do you think? Do I have it all wrong? How comfortable are you with putting pictures of your kids (or future kids) on the internet?
Photo via The Glow. (I loooove The Glow.)